Archive
Papal-critique and 'resistance' media
Archbishop Viganò called Leo XIV's 25 September address in Paris ‘the exact opposite of the Magisterium up to Pius XII’. The text, and the Church's own account of its teaching authority, point to a more limited dispute.
About: Integrity MagazineLifeSiteNewsCarlo Maria Viganò
BriefPapal-critique and 'resistance' media
At the Catholic Identity Conference, Bishop Athanasius Schneider said a ‘hostile takeover’ within the Church’s administrative structure is marked by ‘brazen heresies’ among senior clergy. The reported excerpts name no examples, which limits what can be tested.
About: LifeSiteNewsThe RemnantAthanasius Schneider
Liturgy law: from the 1984 indult to Traditionis custodes
The Diocese of Pittsburgh says a Latin Mass it didn't authorize does not fulfil the Sunday obligation; LifeSiteNews says Quo Primum makes the old Mass permanently free to celebrate. Both claims need context from canon law.
About: LifeSiteNews
BriefThe death penalty
Reporting the Holy See’s call at the UN for abolition, LifeSiteNews says the death penalty is “mandated by divine law” and that denying its permissibility is at least material heresy. The sources it cites speak of a lawful power, not a mandate, and the Church has not defined the point.
About: LifeSiteNews
PreliminaryBriefThe SSPX episcopal consecrations of 2026
LifeSiteNews says the excommunications have “backfired”, with the SSPX listing priests who “just joined” it. The Society’s list mostly shows priests who joined earlier or are drawing closer. Only two of its dated cases come after the July decree.
About: LifeSiteNewsSociety of Saint Pius X (SSPX)
PreliminaryBrief
LifeSiteNews reports that Prof. Vincenzo Rosito praised “the spirit of Amoris Laetitia”, which it says allowed divorced and remarried couples to receive Communion in some cases. That describes the Holy See’s reading of the document fairly. Rosito’s address, though, does not mention Communion.
About: LifeSiteNews
PreliminaryBriefThe SSPX episcopal consecrations of 2026
James Vogel, the SSPX’s communications director, told LifeSiteNews the 2026 excommunications are grave but not infallible, and pointed to three bishops Cardinal Josyf Slipyj consecrated without papal approval in 1977. Both statements check out; the precedent differs in ways that matter.
About: InfoVaticanaLifeSiteNewsSociety of Saint Pius X (SSPX)
PreliminaryBrief
LifeSiteNews says Leo XIV appointed Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle dean of the College of Cardinals, to help coordinate any papal transition during his lifetime. The cardinal bishops elected him and the Pope approved; the term is five years, renewable.
About: LifeSiteNews
BriefSynodality and the Synod on Synodality
LifeSiteNews presents Bishop Rob Mutsaerts' advice to change parishes, and his criticism of synodality, as a bishop "admitting synodality has failed". Catholics are free to worship in another parish; the criticism is one auxiliary bishop's long-held view, not an admission by the Church.
About: LifeSiteNews
BriefAmoris Laetitia and Fiducia Supplicans
Bishop Athanasius Schneider says the Buenos Aires norms open "the door for all sacraments" to remarried couples who cannot live in continence, and that this is "against divine law". The norms add a condition he leaves out; his doctrinal objection reflects a real and unresolved dispute.
About: LifeSiteNewsAthanasius Schneider
PreliminaryBriefSynodality and the Synod on Synodality
LifeSiteNews says Cardinal Filipe Neri Ferrão argued the Church "must accommodate" new forms of cohabitation rather than insist on an ideal family. His address lists cohabitation among changes he observes, and his "ideal family" line comes from Amoris laetitia itself.
About: LifeSiteNews
PreliminaryBrief
LifeSiteNews says the new adjunct secretary of the Dicastery for Evangelization claimed women can "sense a call to priesthood". She did say that, at the 2024 synod. She also said ordained ministry for women was not on the table, and asked only that the discussion continue.
About: LifeSiteNews