Skip to content

OutletsPublication

Crisis Magazine

US Catholic opinion magazine founded in 1982 by Michael Novak and Ralph McInerny; online-only since 2007 and edited since 2021 by Eric Sammons, whose company also owns OnePeterFive.

Est. 1982United Statescrisismagazine.com(opens the outlet’s own site in a new tab)No analyses yet

About Crisis Magazine

Crisis Magazine is an American Catholic opinion magazine. It was launched in November 1982 under the working title Catholicism in Crisis by Michael Novak and Ralph McInerny, reportedly with about $3,000 of their own money; it was first based at Notre Dame and published by the Brownson Institute, and the title was later shortened to Crisis (Crisis Magazine; Wikipedia). Deal W. Hudson became publisher and editor in February 1995, and ownership passed to the Morley Institute he created. The print edition ended in late 2007, when content moved online under the name InsideCatholic; after Sophia Institute Press acquired the magazine in 2011 the Crisis name returned (National Catholic Reporter; Wikipedia). Since 2019 a Crisis-branded book imprint has published titles on social and cultural trends from a Catholic perspective.

Eric Sammons became editor-in-chief in January 2021 and is executive director of Crisis Publications, which acquired OnePeterFive in July 2021 (OnePeterFive; OnePeterFive). The magazine produces the Crisis Point podcast (Crisis Magazine), which in May 2025 discussed how traditional Catholics should respond to Leo XIV (Crisis Point).

Defenders of Pope Francis counted Crisis among his critics: Mike Lewis of the website Where Peter Is listed it with LifeSiteNews, Church Militant and The Wanderer as outlets that had abandoned support for the pope (Millennial Journal).

After the SSPX consecrations of 1 July 2026, Crisis took a line critical of the Society. On 2 July it published an essay, "The SSPX's Foundational Error", arguing that the Society's appeal to a state of necessity does not hold and that the excommunications are legitimate (Crisis Magazine). In editorials that month Sammons argued that much of the confusion over "automatic" excommunication came from misunderstanding the concept, and set out what he called the legitimate options for Catholics attached to the Society, the first being to obey the pope and refrain from association with it (Crisis Magazine; Crisis Magazine). Integrity Magazine described the episode as turning former friends of the Society into foes (Integrity Magazine). See papal-critique and resistance media.

On the timeline

Full timeline

Dated events, newest first.

  1. OnePeterFive under Crisis Publications names Timothy Flanders editor

    Two weeks after announcing that Crisis Publications, led by Eric Sammons, had acquired OnePeterFive from its founder Steve Skojec, the site named Timothy Flanders as editor. Skojec, who had written publicly about a crisis of faith earlier…

    3 sources

    ANNOUNCEMENT: New 1P5 Editor! (OnePeterFive)The Ongoing Mission of OnePeterFive (OnePeterFive)Steve Skojec Has Had Enough (The American Conservative)

Sources for this profile

  1. 20 Years of Crisis Magazine — Crisis Magazine
  2. Crisis (magazine) / Sophia Institute Press — Wikipedia
  3. Crisis Magazine Returns — National Catholic Reporter
  4. Sophia Institute Press — Wikipedia
  5. ANNOUNCEMENT: New 1P5 Editor! — OnePeterFive, Aug 9, 2021
  6. The Ongoing Mission of OnePeterFive — OnePeterFive
  7. Crisis Point Podcast — Crisis Magazine
  8. Traditional Catholics and Pope Leo XIV - Crisis Point — Crisis Point (Castos), May 2025
  9. Defending the Pope from Relentless Right-Wing Dissent and Attacks: An Interview with Mike Lewis — Millennial Journal, Jan 18, 2021
  10. The SSPX's Foundational Error — Crisis Magazine, Jul 2, 2026
  11. Automatic Excommunications Are Never Automatic — Crisis Magazine, Jul 6, 2026
  12. The "Canonical Mess" Excuse Doesn't Fly — Crisis Magazine, Jul 13, 2026
  13. From 'friends' to foes: How the SSPX consecrations broke Trad Inc. — Integrity Magazine, Jul 3, 2026

About this profile

Analyses of Crisis Magazine

We haven’t published an analysis about Crisis Magazine yet. This profile documents public role and public output only.

Latest analyses