Topics: Sedevacantism
On LifeSite, a guest says Cardinal Siri was elected and accepted in 1958 because of white smoke. The record does not show it
In the John-Henry Westen Show, author Gary Giuffre presents the “Siri thesis”: that Cardinal Giuseppe Siri was elected pope in October 1958 and accepted. The confusing smoke of 26 October is well documented; an accepted election is not. Angelo Roncalli was elected on 28 October and took the name John XXIII.
By TradWatch™ staff
2 min read
Share this piece
Verdicts at a glance
- Unsupported
Cardinal Siri was elected pope in 1958 and accepted; the white smoke proves it. · Gary Giuffre
In this brief · 7 sections
In an episode of The John-Henry Westen Show published by LifeSiteNews on 16 October 2026, John-Henry Westen interviews author Gary Giuffre, who argues that Cardinal Giuseppe Siri was elected pope in the October 1958 conclave and accepted, before a threat led to a different outcome. Giuffre rests the claim on an account he says he heard in 1993 from a Vatican diplomat, and on the white smoke seen on 26 October 1958.
What was said
Statement 1: Gary Giuffre
LifeSiteNews (The John-Henry Westen Show) · October 16, 2026
Siri was elected on the fourth ballot to 58 conclave. And he accepted office. He had to accept the office. Otherwise, there would have been no white smoke
In brief: Cardinal Siri was elected pope in 1958 and accepted; the white smoke proves it.
Our verdict: UnsupportedNo evidence was offered, and we found none to support it.
See the recordThis content is embedded for purposes of commentary, criticism, and news reporting. TradWatch is not affiliated with LifeSiteNews (The John-Henry Westen Show). Views quoted are those of the speaker.
Context
The episode goes on to allege a threat delivered inside the conclave, State Department involvement and a later succession of “impostor” popes. Those claims rest on the same unverified premise and are not rated separately here. The Siri thesis is one of several theories used to argue that the popes since 1958 were not valid.
The record
What the sources show, statement by statement.
Verifiable factcan be checked against the sources cited.TradWatch analysisis our interpretation, clearly labelled.Statement 1 · Gary Giuffre
Cardinal Siri was elected pope in 1958 and accepted; the white smoke proves it.
Verifiable fact The smoke confusion was real, and was explained at the time
Newspaper reports read out in the episode itself describe white-looking smoke on the evening of 26 October 1958 and a Vatican Radio announcement that a pope had been elected; the same Associated Press report adds that the confusion lasted until “assurances finally were received from within the conclave that black smoke was intended”. That the smoke looked white is documented; that a candidate had accepted is not.
Source
- 1
Journalism
Featured on Tucker Carlson - the Man Who Claims Evidence of Papal Infiltration
LifeSiteNews (The John-Henry Westen Show) · October 16, 2026
- 1
Verifiable fact Who was elected
Cardinal Angelo Roncalli “was elected Pope on 28 October 1958, taking the name John XXIII” (Holy See biography). Cardinal Siri remained Archbishop of Genoa and a cardinal under John XXIII and his successors.
Source
TradWatch analysis The evidence offered is second-hand
Giuffre’s main source is a conversation in 1993 with a diplomat who, Giuffre says, “did not claim to have been inside the conclave”. White smoke shows what those burning the ballots intended or what the crowd saw, not that an election was accepted; ambiguous smoke has confused crowds at several conclaves. No document or participant’s account published to date establishes that Siri was elected and accepted.
Source
- 1
Journalism
Featured on Tucker Carlson - the Man Who Claims Evidence of Papal Infiltration
LifeSiteNews (The John-Henry Westen Show) · October 16, 2026
- 1
Bottom line
The confusing smoke of 26 October 1958 is well documented, but it does not show that Cardinal Siri was elected and accepted. The election on record is Angelo Roncalli’s, on 28 October 1958.
The original
This content is embedded for purposes of commentary, criticism, and news reporting. TradWatch is not affiliated with LifeSiteNews. Views quoted are those of the speaker.
Sources
- 1.Primary sourceCited in statement 1
Featured on Tucker Carlson - the Man Who Claims Evidence of Papal Infiltration
LifeSiteNews (The John-Henry Westen Show) · October 16, 2026
shows.acast.com/the-john-henry-westen-show/episodes/featured-on-tucker-carlson-…
- 2.Official Church sourceCited in statement 1
Holy See (vatican.va)
vatican.va/content/john-xxiii/en/biography/documents/hf_j-xxiii_bio_20190722_bi…
Corrections & updates
No corrections have been made to this brief. Spotted an error? Request a correction.
We invite the people and outlets discussed here to respond. Submit a response and we’ll publish it alongside this brief.
Help us keep the record straight
If we’ve made a mistake, tell us — we correct errors openly and log every change. People and outlets we write about can respond, and we publish their replies here.
Share this analysis
More analysis
- COVID-19 vaccines and public healthLifeSiteNews says a retracted paper claimed COVID shots gave protective antibodies. The paper tested an experimental vaccine in miceScience Translational Medicine did retract a 2022 Francis Crick Institute paper on 14 October over fabricated data. But the paper studied an experimental vaccine targeting the S2 part of the spike protein, tested in mice, not the COVID-19 vaccines given to the public. The article’s VAERS figures are reports, which the system itself says cannot show that a vaccine caused an event. · 2 min read
- Freemasonry and conspiracy claimsLifeSiteNews says Catholics who join a Masonic lodge are automatically excommunicated. Membership is forbidden and gravely sinful, but the current law sets no automatic excommunicationAnswering an Austrian grand master, LifeSiteNews says the Church punishes any Catholic who joins a lodge with latae sententiae excommunication. That was the rule under the 1917 Code. Since 1983, the Church teaches that Masonic membership remains forbidden and that members are in a state of grave sin and may not receive Communion, while the Code sets a “just penalty” for joining such associations. · 2 min read
- LifeSiteNewsBishop Schneider says the Ordinary Magisterium taught the titles “Coredemptrix” and “Mediatrix of All Graces”. Popes used them; the Vatican now calls the first always inappropriateIn a foreword quoted by LifeSiteNews, Bishop Athanasius Schneider argues that the Church’s Ordinary Magisterium taught these Marian titles over centuries. The Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith’s 2025 note records that popes used “Co-redemptrix”, John Paul II at least seven times, but says the doctrine was judged “not mature” in 1996 and that the title is “always inappropriate”. LifeSiteNews also softens the note’s wording. · 2 min read